Why I will not watch the Nina Simone biopic starring Zoe Saldana…
I went to the movies this weekend and noticed that the Nina Simone biopic was released. Nina Simone. Her name makes me feel several emotions at once…emotions for which words haven’t even been invented yet. Her music has cradled me through some very dark times. Her voices wraps around me like a warm blanket that helps the day melt away. Right now, I’m listening to A Single Woman and remembering sitting on a hilltop in Johannesburg, South Africa feeling lonely…yet invincible.
So how on Earth did a Chicanita from Battle Creek, Michigan get introduced to Nina Simone? Simple…Elsa Barkley Brown, an amazing historian, scholar, and role model. I took a course with Dr. Barkley Brown called Black Women in America. One day she brought in a record player and told us a story of the first time she saw Nina Simone in concert. The energy in the room changed immediately. Dr. Barkley Brown’s face lit up as she shared about how she braved a winter storm just to watch Nina in concert. Despite the bad weather, Miss Simone refused to cancel the concert and gave her small, intimate audience a show for thousands. The song she played in the background as she spoke with us? Mississippi God*amn. From then on, I was hooked. I ran to the CD store (yes a CD store) and bought the only CD I could afford. I worked in a library at the time and convinced them to buy more of her CDs so I could listen to more.
I gulped her music like dry ground drinks rain. Four Women. Black is the Color of my True Love’s Hair. I put a Spell on You. Plain Gold Ring. Her voice is hypnotic, relatable, and painfully beautiful. She sings like she is exhausted but simply cannot help herself because she has to sing. I needed to hear her at the time because The University of Michigan was under scrutiny for its affirmative action policies. When I would tell white people where I went to school many would say, “Oh of course! You’re Hispanic!” One time, during a college visit, I was on a panel and a father stood up in the background and said, “How does it feel knowing that you took my daughter’s spot?” He was white.
Now, I am not someone who knows exactly what to say in the moment. I’m that person who thinks of something cool to say fifteen minutes later. That day, however, the right thing came out of my mouth. The room was super quiet and I said, “Sir, I’m sorry your daughter didn’t get into Michigan. I can assure you, however, that I deserve to be here.” I began to spout off my qualifications and he seemed to relax a little. I said, “I hope that makes you feel a little better…but I have to ask you a question. Who told you that was her spot? Who said it was yours?” I doubt I made him get pensive about privilege, but I made my point.
Later, I relayed the story to Dr. Barkley Brown and shared about how insecure I felt despite my momentary surge of confidence. I likely did get “points” when I applied. Did that mean I needed them in order to get in? She gave me the best advice ever! She said, “Marisela, you need to stop walking around here like Michigan did you a favor by accepting you. You did Michigan a favor! Where else were you accepted?” I told her. “See! You could have gone anywhere! You chose Michigan and Michigan is better for it. Michigan needs students like you with experiences like yours. You make this campus better. You are opening the door for your sisters.” From that day on, I walked around campus like I owned the joint. Young, Gifted, and Black played in my head that day…with a slight change in the lyric perhaps.
When you’re feeling real low,
There’s a great truth you should know,
To be Young, Gifted, and Black [Brown]
Your soul’s intact!
Nina Simone’s music was an essential part of the soundtrack of my life as a Brown woman moving through a predominately white world. So when I first heard about Zoe Saldana being cast as Nina, I was only a bit confused. Perhaps she was a fan too? But I couldn’t help but think, “She doesn’t quite look like her…I didn’t know could sing!…Why her? Why not an African American actress like [fill in the blank…]?”
I really dig Zoe Saldana. She’s an amazing actress. I loved her in Avatar, Guardians, and my personal favorite, Columbiana. [I love it at the end when she says, “Eat!” and the dogs devour the bad guy. What can I say? I have a sick sense of humor]. Then I saw the leaked photos and my heart stopped. I thought, “Ay mija…no..por favor…no! Don’t let them do that to you!” I kept clicking on photos hoping that at least one wouldn’t look so terrible. That maybe…just maybe she did look like Nina and it wouldn’t be so bad. But I have yet to find one. Frankly even if I did…I know I wouldn’t like it.
There is a part of me that desperately wanted to support my fellow Latina. But the part of me that knows and understand the history of race in America and, specifically, the practice of blackface, simply cannot. Yes, she is Afro-Latinx. Yes…she is incredibly talented. But as Eduardo Bonilla-Silva (EBS) often urges: we in Latinx communities have to come to terms with our own troubled notions of race. As Latinos, we don’t call it racism though. We give it cute, racism-lite terms like colorism. It’s colorism…not racism. No, mi familia, it’s straight up racism.
Latinos and race is incredibly complicated. We, as a collective, occupy a middling position within the spectrum of race (O’Brien 2008; Roth 2012). Like beads on an abacus, we can slide back and forth within the Black/White binary depending on our shade, hair, speech, etc…Furthermore, we have our own history of blackface and pushing out Zoe Saldana’s lips, changing her teeth, darkening her already black skin, and giving her a wig is a very insidious form of blackface. I feel like she was used because she was, as a NYC Casting Director in Mears 2010 on race and the fashion industry said, “We want black but not too black.”
I was never more convinced about my feelings as when I saw a meme of Uzo Aduba and Nina Simone side-by-side. I cannot find the original Facebook post, but here is an excellent comparison. Also, there are numerous compelling articles that discuss the bevy of other Black actresses who could have played Nina Simone. I will not revisit those excellent options either.
What I will say, however, is that as a Chicana I have come to recognize when and how White Hollywood pits Black and Brown against one another. This is one of those instances. I value Zoe Saldana and love it when a Latina is on the big screen. But it cannot be at the expense of my Black brothers and sisters. Nina Simone provided a movement with music. Her songs about race and inequality are about blackness in America. Yet…it is also a gift to those of us who also feel marginalized, excluded, forgotten, and ignored. We need to cherish her gift not cheaply imitate it. She and her legacy deserve better.
So, as much as I love supporting Zoe, I will not watch the biopic. Instead, I watched What Happened Miss Simone? on Netflix and fell even more in love with the troubled artist. To find out that she struggled with mental illness was so incredibly liberating. I finally understand why Little Girl Blue still makes me cry to this day.
Mil gracias for reading,
4 thoughts on “Conflicted not colorblind…”
I understand your feelings about Zoe playing Nina. I was hoping her daughter Simone got the part. However I will see the film. I love Nina Simone and her music and I will let you know what I thought of the film.
I agree completely with your feelings about how her music makes you feel. I was fortunate to see her in person a few times and got to meet her once after a show, however it was during a bad time in her life and she was dealing with some demons.
Her music cuts right thru you. She was a special talent.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Love this (and love your entire site). I am disappointed that Hollywood would rather use Black face (or yellow face, or brown face) than hire talented actors of color. Keep writing, chica, you are very talented.
LikeLiked by 1 person
I love this post and your writing/website in general–you are very talented writer, chica!
I think it’s just so sad that Hollywood, in 2016, still would rather put a white or light-skinned POC in blackface (or yellowface or brownface) than hire a talented actor of color that is of the same race/complexion/ethinicity of the person. In this case it is even more disrespectful because of how political and racially conscious Nina was BECAUSE of her complexion and features. I liked your take on it from a fan perspective (of both women).
LikeLiked by 1 person